← Back to All Articles

How to Find Winning Comparable Sales (Comps) for Your Indiana Property Tax Appeal

Published on 2025-05-28 by The Smart Appeal AI Team

#Indiana Property Tax#Tax Appeal#Comparable Sales#Comps#Homeowners#Save Money#Property Assessment#Real Estate Data

If you're appealing your Indiana property tax assessment, one of the most powerful pieces of evidence you can present is a set of well-chosen comparable sales – often called "comps." These are recent sales of properties similar to yours that suggest your assessment is too high. But how do you find winning comps?

This guide will walk you through the process of finding, selecting, and presenting comparable sales for your Indiana property tax appeal.

What Makes a Good Comp?

Not all sales are created equal. For a comp to be persuasive, it should be:

  1. Recent: Ideally, sales should have occurred as close as possible to your property's assessment date (January 1st of the assessment year). Sales within the last year are best. The further away the sale date, the less relevant it becomes.
  2. Similar: The property should be as similar to yours as possible in terms of:
    • Location: In the same neighborhood or a very similar one. The closer, the better.
    • Type of Property: Single-family home, condo, etc.
    • Size: Square footage (both living area and lot size).
    • Age and Condition: Similar age and overall condition.
    • Features: Number of bedrooms/bathrooms, garage, basement, construction style, quality of finishes.
  3. Arm's Length Transaction: The sale should be a fair market transaction between a willing buyer and a willing seller, not a foreclosure, family sale, or other distressed situation.

Where to Find Comparable Sales Data

Several resources can help you find sales data in Indiana:

  • County Assessor/Auditor Websites: Many Indiana counties provide online access to property sales data. This is often the best starting point as it's official data.
  • Real Estate Websites: Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com, etc., can provide recent sales information, though always try to verify details with official sources if possible.
  • Smart Appeal AI: Our platform is designed to help you find and analyze relevant comparable sales data tailored to your property and location in Indiana.
  • Real Estate Agents: A local real estate agent may be willing to provide you with a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA), though there might be a fee if you're not otherwise a client.
  • Appraisers: For complex cases, a professional appraiser can provide a detailed report with comps.

Selecting and Analyzing Your Comps

Once you have a list of potential comps:

  1. Aim for 3-5 Strong Comps: Quality over quantity. Choose the sales that most closely match your property and sold for less than your assessed value (or support a lower value).
  2. Adjust for Differences: No two properties are identical. You may need to make reasonable adjustments for differences. For example:
    • If a comp has an extra bathroom, you might adjust its sale price downwards slightly when comparing to your property.
    • If a comp is in significantly better condition, its sale price might need to be adjusted down.
    • Be prepared to explain your adjustments to the assessor or appeal board.
  3. Visit the Comps (If Possible): Drive by the comparable properties to get a sense of their condition and neighborhood context. This can help you spot discrepancies or confirm similarities.
  4. Document Everything: Keep detailed notes on each comp, including its address, sale date, sale price, key features, and why you believe it's comparable.

Presenting Your Comps Effectively

How you present your comps matters:

  • Clear Summary Table: Create a table that lists your property and each comp, showing key features side-by-side (e.g., sale price, date, square footage, beds/baths).
  • Photographs: Include photos of your property and the comparable properties.
  • Map: A map showing the location of your property and the comps can be very helpful.
  • Written Explanation: Briefly explain why you chose each comp and how it supports your argument for a lower assessment.

Smart Appeal AI Can Help

Finding and analyzing comparable sales can be time-consuming. Smart Appeal AI uses technology to help Indiana homeowners identify strong comps quickly and efficiently, providing data and insights to build a compelling appeal.

Ready to find winning comps for your Indiana property tax appeal? Visit Smart Appeal AI to get started.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. Property tax appeal success depends on the specifics of your case and local procedures. Always verify information with your county assessor's office.